CRCL Capitalizes on Stablecoin Surge—Can It Justify Its Lofty Valuation?

Circle Internet Group (CRCL) just doubled down on the stablecoin gold rush—but Wall Street's still side-eyeing its premium price tag.

Why stablecoins? Because while TradFi plays with Monopoly money, crypto's building actual rails.

The USDC play: CRCL's not just minting digital dollars—it's eating JP Morgan's lunch by settling $50B+ in daily transactions without a single SWIFT fee.

Valuation reality check: Sure, stablecoins are boring profit machines. But at 20x earnings, CRCL's priced like it invented money itself—not just a better version of Wells Fargo's back office.

Bottom line: In a world where 'blockchain' still makes bankers flinch, CRCL's betting that boring wins. Even if the stock's currently priced for moon shots.

Confident Investing Starts Here:

• Easily unpack a company's performance with TipRanks' new KPI Data for smart investment decisions
• Receive undervalued, market resilient stocks right to your inbox with TipRanks' Smart Value Newsletter

While such intense volume draws attention, it also raises questions about valuation, especially compared to giants like Tesla (TSLA), which tops the list with a market cap of over $1 trillion. Given the typical post-IPO volatility and signs of speculative enthusiasm, I’m taking a cautious stance and assigning Circle a Hold rating for the time being, with the sneaking suspicion that what goes up must come down.

Circle’s Premium Offsets Its Distinct Growth

The company’s core business is as the principal issuer of USDC, the second-largest stablecoin globally, with approximately $61 billion in circulation. Circle operates cross-chain on Ethereum, Solana, and other blockchains, making it a critical element of the financial infrastructure of the burgeoning crypto ecosystem. Its revenue is primarily derived from interest on its USDC reserve, which is highly profitable at scale; currently, this accounts for approximately 99% of its revenue.

With the company trading at over 20x its book value, compared to about three times for the sector median, it’s logical to be cautious about buying a position in Circle. In contrast, Coinbase (COIN) has a price-to-book ratio of just 7.5, with year-over-year revenue growth of about 75% compared to about 15% for Circle.

One thing is certain: if you buy Circle stock now, you’re paying a premium, and that’s always a significant setback in achieving world-class returns. Circle currently has positive earnings per share, which lends it a degree of operational credibility, and I expect these earnings to grow rapidly in the coming years. Still, the stock is currently trading at a stark 220x forward earnings.

However, from a macro perspective, the tailwinds for strong returns are substantial. The stablecoin market is expected to grow from approximately $260 billion to $1–2 trillion or more over the long term. There are also specific near-term catalysts that can support Circle in maintaining momentum to capitalize on this expanding market opportunity. In some sense, this substantiates the current premium valuation.

Strategic Catalysts Secure Circle’s Return Horizon

Circle has teamed up with fintech giant Fiserv (FI) to launch FIUSD, a new stablecoin built on the fast and cost-efficient solana blockchain. This partnership could unlock significant revenue streams for Circle through transaction fees, reserve income from fiat-backed collateral, and integrations with key payment players like Mastercard (MA) and PayPal (PYPL).

The regulatory environment is also improving. The GENIUS Act, expected to pass the House soon, lays the groundwork for stablecoin legitimacy, boosting confidence in Circle’s USDC as a go-to solution for banks, fintech firms, and corporate treasuries.

Investor sentiment is largely bullish, with endorsements from Seaport Global and heavy backing from Cathie Wood’s ARK Invest, which has made Circle a top-five holding in its flagship ETF. Still, despite the optimism, Circle’s lofty valuation raises questions about whether it’s priced for perfection, making it less clear if this is a long-term winner or just a hot name in the moment.

Is Circle Internet Group a Buy, Sell, or Hold?

Since its sudden re-rating, several analysts have compiled research notes and provided ratings on the stock. On Wall Street, CRCL stock carries a Moderate Buy consensus rating based on one Buy, two Hold, and zero Sell ratings over the past three months. CRCL’s average stock price target of $213.33 implies less than 1% upside potential over the next twelve months. Clearly, analysts are apprehensive.

Even though there is burgeoning bullish sentiment that may have some legs, given current cyclicality on the horizon from low interest rates lowering the yield CRCL will earn on its USDC reserves, I’d wait for a near-term pullback before pulling the trigger on buying the shares.

CRLC Bulls May Have the Last Laugh

Circle’s current valuation is exceptionally rich and could come under pressure if interest rates decline, which is widely expected over the next year. In the medium term, tighter regulation and increased competition may weigh on margins, while long-term exposure to cyclical crypto sentiment remains a risk.

That said, the company holds a serious long-term promise as digital dollars gain traction across fintech and traditional finance. With a scalable, high-margin model, Circle could evolve into a digital payments powerhouse akin to a modern-day Visa (V). If regulatory clarity holds and pro-crypto sentiment continues under future administrations, the long-term thesis is compelling.

Still, I’m not buying just yet. The stock appears too expensive at current levels, especially considering other high-growth bets like CoreWeave (CRWV) are also out there. While I remain bullish over the long run, I’m maintaining a Hold rating for now, with plans to revisit the stock after a meaningful pullback—ideally in a lower-rate environment.