C3.ai Stock Plunge: Smart Dip-Buy or AI Hype Trap?

Another day, another tech stock getting tossed around like a meme coin. C3.ai's latest nosedive has traders asking: Is this a golden opportunity or another overhyped AI play burning retail investors?

Bulls see blood in the water—bears see another unprofitable tech story. The company's enterprise AI solutions promise transformation, but Wall Street's patience wears thinner than a layer-1 blockchain during congestion.

Remember: In this market, 'buying the dip' just means catching a different set of falling knives. But hey—at least you're not stuck holding bags of some shitcoin, right?

Image source: Getty Images.

Some companies wouldn't be the same without their leadership

Not all CEO departures are the same. Abrupt ones without any forewarning are the most concerning. While this departure falls into this category, it's for an unfortunate reason. Siebel was diagnosed with an autoimmune disease and has begun the search for his replacement. While he has mostly recovered from this disease, he believes that he cannot handle the rigorous demands of being the CEO of a rapidly growing AI company, which is why a new person is needed to lead C3.ai.

While this is sad, investors need to understand that this happens from time to time in the market and assess if they were investing in C3.ai for the company or its leadership. There are countless examples of companies that wouldn't be the same without their leader. One prime example is's (TSLA -1.83%) Elon Musk. Whether you love him, don't like him, or are neutral doesn't matter -- the company WOULD be different without him at the helm.

So, is it worth scooping up C3.ai shares at a discount without Siebel at the helm?

C3.ai is delivering strong growth at the cost of profitability

C3.ai provides turnkey AI solutions for its customers, making it a great option to get up and running in the AI game. Additionally, it has won several government contracts to develop AI solutions within the U.S. Defense Department.

This has led to strong growth for the company, with C3.ai's revenue rising 25% year over year in fourth-quarter fiscal year 2025 (ending April 30). It also expects strong growth for FY 2026, with revenue expected to be about $466 million, up 20% from FY 2025's $389 million.

That projection is unlikely to shift with a new CEO eventually at the helm, so the big change will be where C3.ai heads after this year.

C3.ai is at a crossroads as a company, and who Siebel and the board decide to bring on as a replacement will give investors a clue about what direction C3.ai is heading. Right now, it's a growth-at-all-costs business. This is evidenced by its poor profitability.

AI Profit Margin data by YCharts.

While C3.ai has made some improvements in its profitability, it remains a long way from turning a profit.

Who C3.ai decides to bring on as CEO will clue investors in as to where the company is heading next. It could bring on an operations-focused CEO who works toward shifting the company to be profitable, potentially at the cost of some revenue growth. Another option is to bring on a CEO who's growth-oriented and maintains C3.ai's current path.

I think it would be smart to strike a balance between these two traits, but I'll have to wait and see who C3.ai brings on before I can make a final decision.

As a result, I think investors should be patient and see who C3.ai decides to hire, then make a call from there. If you already own shares, there's no reason to sell. But I'd be cautious about adding until there is some clarity regarding who will lead the company.