Sony Slams Tencent’s "Nonsense" Defense in 2025 Horizon Ripoff Lawsuit
- What’s the Core of Sony’s Lawsuit Against Tencent?
- How Has Tencent Responded to the Allegations?
- What’s the Financial Stakes in This Legal Battle?
- Why Is Jurisdiction a Key Issue in the Case?
- What Do Gamers and Critics Say About the Controversy?
- Could This Lawsuit Reshape Gaming IP Law?
- What’s Next in the Legal Fight?
- *
The legal battle between Sony and Tencent over the alleged ripoff of Sony’s Horizon franchise has escalated, with Sony dismissing Tencent’s defense as "nonsense." Sony claims Tencent’sis a blatant clone, while Tencent argues it’s using common genre tropes. The lawsuit, filed in 2025, could set a precedent for intellectual property in gaming. Here’s a DEEP dive into the clash of these gaming titans.
What’s the Core of Sony’s Lawsuit Against Tencent?
Sony Interactive Entertainment (SIE) has accused Tencent of copyright infringement and trademark violation, alleging thatis a shameless knockoff of itsseries. In a 35-page court filing, SIE detailed how Tencent’s game replicates specific elements—mechanical monsters, red-haired protagonists, and post-apocalyptic settings—with eerie similarity. Sony claims the copying is so blatant that even fans have called it out. "The damage is already done," SIE argues, pointing to promotional materials still visible on platforms like YouTube and Steam.
How Has Tencent Responded to the Allegations?
Tencent fired back, calling Sony’s claims "startling" and an attempt to monopolize genre conventions. The Chinese tech giant argues thatuses time-honored tropes found in games likeand. Tencent’s legal team insists Sony is overreaching by trying to claim ownership of broad storytelling elements. "Sony isn’t protecting creativity—it’s fencing off ideas that have been in games for decades," a Tencent spokesperson said.
What’s the Financial Stakes in This Legal Battle?
The lawsuit could have significant financial implications for both companies. Sony’sfranchise has generated over $1 billion in revenue (source: TradingView), and any dilution of its IP could hurt future earnings. Tencent, meanwhile, is the world’s largest gaming company by revenue (source: CoinMarketCap), and a loss here could embolden other studios to challenge its practices. Investors are watching closely, as the outcome may influence how aggressively companies defend their IP in the future.
Why Is Jurisdiction a Key Issue in the Case?
Sony alleges Tencent is playing a "corporate shell game" to avoid liability by shuffling responsibilities among subsidiaries. For example, Tencent Holdings holds the U.S. trademark for, but Tencent Games operates the brand. Sony argues this structure is a deliberate attempt to obscure accountability. Legal experts say jurisdiction battles like this are becoming common in global IP disputes, especially when multinational corporations are involved.
What Do Gamers and Critics Say About the Controversy?
The gaming community is divided. Some players have mockedas a "budget Horizon," while others defend Tencent’s right to iterate on genre conventions. Critics note that while the similarities are striking, proving intentional copying in court is tricky. "This case could redefine what counts as inspiration versus theft in gaming," said a BTCC market analyst.
Could This Lawsuit Reshape Gaming IP Law?
If Sony wins, it might encourage more studios to litigate against perceived clones, potentially stifling indie developers who rely on genre staples. A Tencent victory, however, could weaken IP protections for AAA titles. Either way, the ruling will likely Ripple across the industry. As one legal scholar put it, "This isn’t just about two games—it’s about where we draw the line between homage and theft."
What’s Next in the Legal Fight?
Sony has urged the court to reject Tencent’s motion to dismiss, citing the global release of’s promotional materials as evidence of harm. Tencent, meanwhile, is doubling down on its argument that Sony’s claims are premature. The case is expected to drag into 2026, with both sides preparing for a costly battle. For now, gamers are left to debate: Isa rip-off or just another open-world adventure?
*
What is Sony accusing Tencent of?
Sony alleges Tencent’sis a deliberate copy of itsseries, infringing on copyrights and trademarks.
How has Tencent responded?
Tencent calls Sony’s claims an overreach, arguing it’s using common genre tropes that can’t be monopolized.
What are the financial stakes?
The lawsuit could impact billions in revenue and set precedents for how gaming IP is protected globally.
Why does jurisdiction matter?
Sony claims Tencent is using subsidiaries to avoid liability, making legal accountability more complicated.
What’s the gaming community saying?
Players and critics are split, with some calling it a rip-off and others defending Tencent’s creative rights.
