Carnival Cruise Lines Stock (NYSE:CCL) Slips as Unpleasant Question Emerges: How Bad is Crime on Cruise Ships?

Carnival Cruise investors face choppy waters as safety concerns surface.

Security Under Scrutiny

Passenger safety questions trigger stock volatility amid growing consumer awareness. The floating resort industry faces increased regulatory pressure as incident reports circulate.

Market Reaction

Carnival shares dip as analysts reassess risk profiles. The leisure sector watches closely—because nothing sinks investor confidence faster than customers worrying about their safety.

Industry Implications

Cruise operators navigate turbulent PR waters while maintaining operational continuity. Another reminder that in hospitality, perception often outweighs financial metrics—until it doesn't.

Elevate Your Investing Strategy:

• Take advantage of TipRanks Premium at 50% off! Unlock powerful investing tools, advanced data, and expert analyst insights to help you invest with confidence.

A new report out says that not only is crime on cruise ships a thing, but it is also worse than you might expect. Crime rates on cruise ships are continuing to rise, and they actually reached a two-year high this year. Perhaps that is because people are actually starting to cruise again, after several years of COVID-19-related delay. But regardless of the cause, the numbers are going entirely the wrong way.

In fact, the reports noted, just in the period of January 2025 to March 2025, there were 48 cruise ship crimes reported to the FBI. And of that number, fully one in four—12 total—happened on a Carnival vessel. Yet given the recommendations offered up by Jenni Fielding, a “cruise content creator,” perhaps the problem is not so pronounced. Fielding recommends cruisers “…lock your cabin door at night, avoid leaving drinks unattended and never go into someone’s stateroom alone.”

Growing Competitive Concerns

Meanwhile, there was further bad news for Carnival in a roundabout fashion, as Meyer Turku in Finland signed a new agreement with Royal Caribbean Group (RCL) for ship construction. Meyer Turku has been building ships for Royal Caribbean for the last 30 years now, roughly, and just landed a “firm order” for a fifth ship in the Icon class, a “mega cruise ship.” It also has an option for a seventh ship to come later.

With Royal Caribbean adding on to its fleet, and Carnival looking a little less than SAFE based on those crime statistics, concern over Carnival’s long-term future might be warranted. What also might be warranted is a bit of aggressive marketing defining specific measures Carnival is taking to not only ensure a good time, but a safe one as well.

Is Carnival Cruise Stock a Good Buy Right Now?

Turning to Wall Street, analysts have a Moderate Buy consensus rating on CCL stock based on 11 Buys, three Holds and one Sell assigned in the past three months, as indicated by the graphic below. After a 70.23% rally in its share price over the past year, the average CCL price target of $34.73 per share implies 14.64% upside potential.

Disclosure