Circle’s Stock Plummets 39.5% in a Week—From $299 High to $181
Circle’s market rollercoaster hits a brutal dip—losing nearly 40% of its value in just seven days. Was it overhyped, or is this a buying opportunity?
The numbers don’t lie: a $299 peak now buried under a $181 reality check. Traders scramble as the crypto-adjacent stock mimics the volatility of the assets it services.
Finance’s latest 'stable' darling? Not so much. Maybe next time, Wall Street will remember that what goes up… usually crashes harder.
Needham, Canaccord, and Bernstein forecast strong upside
Needham’s John Todaro gave Circle a buy rating with a $250 price target, which is 39% higher than Friday’s close. Todaro believes that stablecoins are growing fast and sees USDC leading the pack. He said, “We view stablecoins as a fast-growing, paradigm-shifting part of the financial ecosystem; we expect USDC to be dominant within.” He added that Circle’s position could support a premium valuation like Tesla or top AI firms.
Canaccord Genuity also gave Circle a buy rating and set their target at $247, projecting a 37% upside. Their analysts said, “Big run-up post IPO means short-term valuation a risk factor; but sheer TAM size, improving regulatory backdrop, and early market leadership all point to a much larger business medium term; DCF analysis is supportive.”
Gautam Chhugani at Bernstein took a similar stance, initiating coverage at outperform and setting the price at $230, or 27% above the current value. He explained:
“CRCL is building a market-leading digital dollar stablecoin network, with a strong regulatory edge, liquidity headstart and marquee distribution partnerships. This is hard to replicate, in our view. We view CRCL as an investor must-hold, to participate in the new internet-scale financial system built for the next decade.”
Barclays gave Circle an overweight rating with a $215 price target, or 19% upside. Analyst Ramsey El-Assal said: “As blockchain technology is integrated into the traditional financial ecosystem, we view CRCL as one of the only ways for public company investors to play the theme. A steady drumbeat of stablecoin-related news should send shares higher.”
Goldman, JPMorgan, and Deutsche issue bearish calls
Deutsche Bank wasn’t as confident. They gave Circle a hold rating and set a $155 price target, which is 14% below the current value. Their note warned that the stablecoin industry could see wide swings and earnings volatility.
“We see the shares as being fairly valued,” they said, “but we WOULD wait for better opportunities before starting a position.”
Goldman Sachs went further and slapped a neutral rating with a target of $83 — that’s a 54% drop from Friday’s closing price. Analyst James Yaro said:
“CRCL is a unique asset in the public markets, as the only pure play crypto-native company that has potential upside from expansion into very large existing fiat markets, without the direct price volatility inherent to crypto trading. CRCL’s main product, USDC, is a stablecoin meant to represent USD on blockchain … We view CRCL’s business and growth attractively, but valuation appears elevated.”
Oppenheimer didn’t set a price but gave a perform rating. Their note framed Circle as a clean way to get exposure to crypto disrupting traditional markets, including money markets, real estate, and consumer payments. They also emphasized USDC’s potential to become a globally compliant on-chain currency for transactions.
JPMorgan gave the harshest call. They issued a perform rating with an $80 price target, implying a 56% downside. The bank still respects the team behind the company. “We think highly of the Circle management team and are confident in the outlook for outsized stablecoin and USDC growth,” said JPMorgan.
Cryptopolitan Academy: Want to grow your money in 2025? Learn how to do it with DeFi in our upcoming webclass. Save Your Spot
