Investors Pile Into VIX Holdings as Costs Skyrocket - Here’s Why It Matters

Fear gauge positions surge while expenses mount - a classic Wall Street paradox unfolds.

The Volatility Gambit

Traders ramp up VIX exposure despite soaring carrying costs. They're betting big on market turbulence ahead.

Costs Climb, Positions Grow

Contango bleed accelerates as more capital flows into volatility products. The math looks brutal - but fear trumps fundamentals.

Smart Money or Desperation Play?

Institutional investors lead the charge while retail traders follow. Some see insurance, others see panic buying in a market that's forgotten what risk management means.

Another day in finance where paying premium for protection becomes the norm - because who needs profits when you can have peace of mind?

Investors increase VIX holdings while costs mount

Michael Thompson, co-portfolio manager at Little Harbor Advisors, said “these can increase in price pretty dramatically, almost like an option but without an expiration date.” He added that if a correction doesn’t happen on schedule, “you can still hold on to your long vol ETP shares.”

These vehicles offer a basic hedge for investors who own stocks because the VIX tends to rise when the S&P 500 falls. Unlike the 2018 rush into short-volatility trades that led to “Volmageddon,” the current surge in hedging isn’t expected to set off a market shock.

Retail traders are “looking to do something cautious, something protective,” said Rocky Fishman, founder of the research firm Asym 500. He estimated that 40% of open interest in VIX futures is now held by exchange-traded products.

But carrying these bets costs real money. UVIX charges an expense ratio of 2.8% and now holds two VIX futures expiring in October and November. Each day it sells part of October and buys November until October expires, then shifts November into December.

Because October trades below November, the fund sells low and buys high, draining cash. Rolling contracts also pushes down the front-month future and lifts the next-month bet.

“They have to sell the front one and buy the second one on a daily basis to keep their expiration at a weighted 30 days,” said Matthew Thompson, Michael’s brother and co-portfolio manager. “It stands to reason that the front two months should steepen, which, ironically, increases the carrying cost of those instruments.”

Strategists outline VIX curve trades as hedge funds join rush

This rolling problem has happened before. More than a decade ago, retail investors piled into the United States Oil Fund ETF to mimic crude gains but saw returns trail spot prices. Today, implied volatility (the market’s view of future price swings) stays muted as stocks grind higher.

Small realized moves make options cheaper and hold down the spot VIX index and front-month futures. That has left the VIX futures curve steep, with both opportunities and risks.

Strategists at Societe Generale SA have suggested trades to exploit the discount known as contango, noting that the curve is also concave — it steepens NEAR expiration. One idea is selling the near-term VIX future and buying the next month because the front contract tends to sink faster.

But there’s a clear hazard. Brian Fleming and Kunal Thakkar said “the main risk is a sharp and volatile equity selloff, which manifests itself through the VIX curve moving upwards and inverting significantly.”

Some investors see the losses as the cost of protection against a market drop. Hedge funds also use these products for quick trades.

The smartest crypto minds already read our newsletter. Want in? Join them.