Should Ethereum Maximize Profits? The Billion-Dollar Question Shaking Crypto

Ethereum's profit paradox splits the crypto world—purists demand decentralization, capitalists chase returns. Can the network balance idealism with institutional cash?

The Protocol Profit Tug-of-War

Ethereum's shift to proof-of-stake turned validators into profit-seekers overnight. Transaction fees now flow directly to stakeholders—sparking debates about whether the chain should prioritize revenue over principles. Some call it evolution; others scream betrayal.

Institutional Onslaught vs. Core Values

BlackRock’s ETH ETF filing dumped rocket fuel on the fire. Traditional finance wants returns, not philosophical debates—they’d monetize Satoshi’s whitepaper if they could. Meanwhile, developers warn profit-maximization could centralize power among whale validators, undermining Ethereum’s foundational ethos.

The Delicate Balance

Ethereum must navigate Wall Street’s greed without becoming its puppet. Fee structures, validator incentives, and Layer-2 integrations all face pressure to prioritize profitability. One wrong move risks alienating the community that built it—or worse, turning ETH into just another asset for suits to exploit between golf games.

Profit isn’t evil—but worshipping it burns down everything else. Ethereum’s real test? Making bank without selling its soul.

The Walt Disney way

Ward Kimball attributed Walt Disney’s riches to never trying to become rich: “If you want to know the real secret of Walt’s success, it’s that he never tried to make money. He was always trying to make something he could be proud of.” 

Disney told his staff never to mention costs to him — if something made a film or his parks better, he wanted it in, whatever the price.

He built a zoo on the studio lot so animators could study animals while making Bambi. He insisted that the gargoyles on Disney World castles, too high up for anyone to see, be sculpted in full detail.

For Disney, animation and theme parks were passion projects that he pursued against all financial advice, often to the brink of bankruptcy.

It worked out in the end, of course — which proves that sometimes, the most profit-maximizing thing is to not maximize profits.

In other cases, the most profit-maximizing thing is to not make profits at all.

Linus Torvalds, for example, made his fortune by offering the Linux operating system for free. Forever.

It’s easy to imagine Torvalds would now be even wealthier if he charged even a few cents for the use of Linux — billions of devices run on the software he invented, from which he collects exactly $0.

But Linux became a global phenomenon precisely because it was free to use and free to build on — a freedom that turned users into contributors.

Torvalds developed Linux with the help of thousands of enthusiasts eager to contribute to the open-source project simply because they believed in it.

With access to the source code, users didn’t just report bugs to Torvalds — they often sent him the fix, too.

In the early days of its development, this allowed Torvalds to release updated Linux kernels as often as every day. 

It’s impossible to imagine Microsoft releasing new versions of Windows every day. 

It’s equally impossible to imagine that Linux could have been built any other way.  

Today, Torvalds is variously estimated to be worth between $50 and $150 million — a big number, for sure. But also a tiny slice of the unmeasurable value Linux has created for the world. 

Still, a tiny slice of a giant number is generally better than a giant slice of a small one. 

If Torvalds had charged for Linux, his slice might have been 100% of nothing.

Unlike Linux, Ethereum can’t be free — the chain won’t work unless there’s a cost to using it.

But it doesn’t have to maximize profits, either. 

And perhaps it shouldn’t?

By pricing their products and services as commodities, companies like Walmart, Costco, Southwest Airlines and Vanguard became giants by prioritizing growth and revenue over profit margins.

If blockspace is similarly a commodity product, the best way to maximize profits may be not to.

• The Breakdown: Decoding crypto and the markets. Daily.
• 0xResearch: Alpha in your inbox. Think like an analyst.
• Empire: Crypto news and analysis to start your day.
• Forward Guidance: The intersection of crypto, macro and policy.
• The Drop: Apps, games, memes and more.
• Lightspeed: All things Solana.
• Supply Shock: Bitcoin, bitcoin, bitcoin.